(If you have no interest it knowledge of Catholicism or the traditionalist movement in Catholicism, then this post is not for you. If you are interested or just curious, go ahead and read.)
You suck! You’re superiority complex in regards to Latin and tradition is appalling and a huge turn off to those interested in the history of the Catholic Church. Also, your over-the-top favoritism of the 1950s Cleavers society is not a Catholic Golden Age as you make it out to be.
People do not want to go back to a time with incipent sexism, racism, society approved abuse of women and children, and shunning of those who are just a little bit different as worse than slime on a snake’s belly. Women especially do not want to go back to being beaten and raped and told by everyone that it is their fault unless it involves a black man and a white woman then we all know it’s because of the color of his skin so therefore he is totally guilty.
The Golden Age of Catholicism never existed, as you purport. It didn’t happen in the 1950s and it didn’t happen any other time in America because America has almost always been a Protestant nation if it was any kind of Christian nation. Which it hasn’t. Quit buying into fundamentalist ideology about the US. It makes you look stupid.
Traditionalists, when you advocate private, personal devotions as Divine Revelation that must be followed or else and that means Satan has taken over, you make yourself sound stupid. And again, you sound like you’re parroting fundamentalists but with a Catholic wash. Also, hyping on pants on women, women covering their heads, women are only to be wives and mothers having 20 kids who all become priests (if boys) and get married and have more kids (if girls), required homeschooling because institutional schools are godless bastions of homosexuality, strict umbilical gender roles, advocating corporal punishments from twisted interpretation of Scripture, and all the other extrabiblical rules that fundamentalists use and enforce makes you look like misogynist and hater whose God is all about punishing and rules instead of love.
Some of us are so turned off by your words and behavior that we are convinced we should only attend a EF Mass if we believe and act in the same vitriolic manner as you. We come to this conclusion because the only Traditionalists we come in contact with are the rude, misogynistic, violent, vitriol spewing ones who seen to have no love for anyone.
At one point in my life, I may have been open to attending an EF. NOT anymore. All of that is due to you behavior and attitude that God loves you more, even more than the Pope because you attend an EF and hold to tradition.
Well, guess what. I hold to Catholic Tradition too. Tradition that is defined and allowed by Holy Mother Church. Not to your personal, narrow definition. You may say I’m not a Catholic because I don’t attend the EF or veil or think that because I’m a woman that the only thing I’m good for is giving birth to babies to be spanked. But I Am Catholic. Holy Mother Church says so and her opinion matter much more than yours ever will.
Yes, I attend the OF. That doesn’t make me a heretic.
Yes, I believe and accept what Holy Mother Church teaches.
Yes, I wear pants to Mass.
Yes, I don’t veil because that is my choice and I don’t have a problem if women veil as long as it is THEIR CHOICE and are not manipulated into it.
Yes, I don’t pray the Rosary everyday though I do pray and can usually manage a decade of the Rosary most days.
Yes, I have two college degrees and work.
Yes, I do not plan on getting married or having kids.
Yes, I am a faithful Catholic that does her best, attends Mass, goes to Confession when necessary, and works on loving my neighbor and God.
I get that to a Traditionalist I’m going directly to Hell, do not pass Go, do not collect $200 but that’s your problem because it is your belief not mine or Holy Mother Church’s.
So to Traddies: Go Procreate with yourself. The rest of us are going to love God and neighbor because God loves us.
( Sorry, bit of a rant after visiting CAF and reading some of the threads there, especially some of the ones in the Traditional Catholicism section and the superiority complex some, thankfully not all, have on that particular sub-forum. Some seen hellbent on alienating and excluding people to tradition and even are own history in the name of Tradition. Like I said, it’s a huge turnoff and a large option of it is done by people who are younger than me and I’m 31. There are a few in their teens and very early twenties that talk down to and even ridicule their elders on that forums. Even I was taught to respect people I don’t agree with regardless of their age. Manners.get jettisoned all for the sake of God, Catholicism, and tradition.)